Challenge: Pawel Kryszak: Poland

[PoopaScoop]

I think u should make the end of the gun yellow
just a tad to many plane grey objects

[jasiu]

i was considering this option, but if deadline gets extended, maybe I'll reconsider;)

[ashras99]

i was considering this option, but if deadline gets extended, maybe I'll reconsider;)

No extension now, challenge is closed and details posted in "Read before posting" page.

[jasiu]

another anaglyph:P experimenting with stuff

[Sir C]

Nice work man!.

Can you post a side by side image to see it in crosseye?

[jasiu]

side to side:)

[jasiu]

and how does it look? i can't say because i don't have proper equipment.

[Sir C]

First of all you already have equipment, your eyes!. You can see 3D images using the cross-eye view method. Here is an explanation of how to do it: http://www.3dexpo.com/crosseye.htm

Important note: this method works if the combined images are set inverted, I meant, left image in the right side, and right image in the left side.

Second the image is great, the only thing is that the cyan smoke coming from the gun looks strange, it looks like a part of the cloud coming in front of the gun, I think is because that part have a little contrast, then is a little 3d information.

Third I bet that you will soon have another 22' 3D equipment!

[jasiu]

this cross eye thing is to difficult for me:P i can't see anything... Yeah, this blue smoke from gun is problematic, when i was compositing I shouldn;t have chosen an ADD blend mode for this one, but screen:/

[yuriythebest]

awesome image but you are still thinking in 2d. the gun barely pops out- what you should do is rotate the arm so the gun is pointing more torward the 'audience'. The background smoke looks.. well.. strange. I guess it's cause it's meant to look huge but is actually just behind the character- this kind of cheating just won't work (if that's indeed what you did here).

[jasiu]

yuriy- It wasn't my intention for the gun to be directed towards audience and it pops out even too much for me, also, i didn't cheat with the smoke, i didn't also to make it big, its behind a character, not a miles away. Thinking in 3d is not pointing everything in audience i suppose. Thanks for your critique anyway:P

[PoopaScoop]

Yuri I'm actually a quite surprise at your comments as they seem unjustified and crudely put!

I gather that what your referring to, by the gun change, is the image would have more dynamic perspective? But, If the gun was aimed at the audience the composition wouldn't work and there would be huge spaces of nothing.

And the smoke in the scene, is faded out so much by the atmosphere - between it and the character - that I have to ask, how can you possible think it is so close to the character to be a problem?

[losonck]

Great work, I like it very much and hope the judges will too!

[chaitanyak]

congratulations dude!!! You deserve it!! The image turned out as great as i expected it to be

[rdcanime]

Congrates man..!!
Well its not kind of surprising as your victory was already expected

Rock on..!!